Setauket Pastaria

Reviews about Setauket Pastaria

• 1 / 5

  By Robert Davis
  Had a $100+ take out order on New Year's Day. The food was close to embarrassing to serve to visiting family. Children and adults alike found the meatballs and spaghetti dinners, various hero sandwiches and two different pizzas universally not appealing and not worth finishing! Most of the food purchased was thrown out. The plain pizza had a soggy crust, was overly salty and could only be compared to a supermarket frozen variety. The meatball/mushroom was only slightly better. Go to Colloseo, Manhattan or Carnival for pizza. The hero sandwiches were on soft, whitbread type rolls which lacked the crisp crust that makes a hero a "hero". Had trouble telling the difference between the chicken parm, shrimp parm and the veal parm. Too much breading on the fried food. The meatballs were average at best- usually can get better at Costco, Uncle Giuseppe etc.
  Last time for food at this inadequate establishment. Too many better choices in the area.
  October 09, 2016
• 4 / 5

  By Eva Rose Davis
  We happened upon this pizzeria when my son moved in to the area. It is now an almost weekly staple. The staff is generous and kind and very welcoming. We generally stick to the wonderful variety of pizzas, but have recently started sampling salads and soups. I'm an autism mom, it means an incredible amount that my son feels comfortable here and has explored their menu.
  July 08, 2016